|
John
Hatcher, director of education for the Center for Community
Journalism, wanted to find the Greatest Writing Tip the World
Has Ever Seen. He asked top newsroom trainers for their favorite
writing tips and boiled them down into 23 tips on writing.
This list of tips was composed with the help of the NewsCoach
listserv, hosted by The Poynter Institute.
Want
to know how it all happened? In John's own words: "...
I was going to share a piece of advice that would transform
writing just by its very mention."
"We'd call it the Greatest Writing Tip the World Has
Ever Seen."
Want the full version? Click here:
Journalists dare to take
on the ultimate writing quest
Hatcher
is also a Sunday columnist for the Daily Messenger in Canandaigua,
N.Y. Contact him at jhatcher@oswego.edu
or by calling (315) 312-5640.
|
|
The
Greatest Writing Tips the World has Ever Seen
"The
best tip I ever heard was "Go to law school." I think this had
as much
to do with this person's assessment of my talent as it did with the state
of
the newspaper business." -- John Burr, The Florida Times-Union
- Writing checklist
Recommended by: Avi Bass, Northern Illinois University
Good Writing has:
· accurate information
· interesting phrasing
· appropriate word choices
· clear transitions
· no misplaced modifiers
· parallel construction
· proper sequence of tenses
· correct grammar
· correct spelling and punctuation
Assignment: Go through an article and decide what kind of grade it should
receive on each of the above categories on a scale of 1 to 10.
- The great lede
test
Recommended by: Kathy Norton, Poughkeepsie Journal
Read the lede for an article. Now ask, does this sentence make you want
to read the next sentence and the rest of the story?
Assignment: Go through a series of articles, reading only the lede.
After you read the lede, vote as a group on whether you are enticed
to read the rest of the story. Talk about what it does (or doesn't do)
that draws you into the story.
- Finding the
focus
Recommended by: Chip Scanlan, Poynter Institute
Every story is about something. The best stories have a focus and a
point. Try asking these questions:
What's the news? What's the story? What information surprised me the
most? What will surprise my reader or viewer? What one thing does my
reader need to know?
Assignment: Read one story as a group and then see if you can answer
the questions above regarding that article. When you're done, see if
asking these questions helped you decide if you'd change the way the
story you read was put together.
- Active language
Recommended by: Denny Wilkins, St. Bonaventure University
Everyone tells you to write using an "active voice." Anyone
ever tell you how to do that? Here's one suggestion.
Assignment: Try going through a story and highlighting every "are,"
"is," "were," and "was." Now find a way
to rewrite the sentence using a stronger verb.
- Edit your own
copy
Recommended by: Denny Wilkins, St. Bonaventure University
Assignment: It's almost impossible to edit your own copy. But try this
out. Print out a copy of your article and read it backwards. This should
help you see your copy through fresh eyes. Find any errors or awkward
phrases?
- Circling problem
areas
Recommended by: Denny Wilkins, St. Bonaventure University
Assignment: Go through an article and circle every period using a bright
highlighter. Now look at the pattern of periods - looking for areas
where you see longer sentences. See if this helps you identify sentences
that may be too long. Typically, longer sentences are where you find
grammatical errors, needless prepositions and other impediments to good
writing. See if the story has a good balance of long and short sentences.
- Show me the
details
Recommended by: Rene Kaluza, Day city editor/training editor, St. Cloud
Times
Show, don't tell. (However, you have to have reported the details well
to be able to do that.)
Assignment: Go through an article and find examples where a writer could
have benefited from using details to show the reader something rather
than just telling them about it. Also, find examples where the writer
succeeded in showing you something.
- Finding the
nutgraf
Recommended by: Nancy Weil, Assistant News Editor, IDG News Service
Highlight the nutgraf or put it in bold or whatever and go back to it
as you write to make certain that the story supports it.
Assignment: Highlight the nutgraf (the sentence that provides an overview
for what the story is about) and then go through and find places where
the article gets away from the main focus outlined in this nutgraf.
- Quote alert
Recommended by: Nancy Weil, Assistant News Editor, IDG News Service
Go on quote alert. Make sure every quote you use is worth using. Otherwise
paraphrase.
Assignment: Go through an article and highlight the quotes. Decide if
it's an effective quote. Does it add to the story? Why? Should it be
shorter? Should it be longer? Should it be paraphrased?
- Omit needless
words
Recommended by: Nancy Weil, Assistant News Editor, IDG News Service
Be on guard for words you don't need. Watch for phrases like "in
order to" and others that add words without saying more.
Assignment: Go through an article and highlight all the words that can
be eliminated without changing the meaning of the story.
- What's the story
worth?
Recommended by: Antoni M. Piqué, Director, Mediaccion Consultores
/ Universidad de Navarra, Spain
Would you pay 50 cents (or 0,90 euros, or the price of your paper) tomorrow
for THIS piece you are writing?
Assignment: Go through an issue of a newspaper and find one story that
makes the paper worth the price you paid for it. What makes the story
worth the money? If you can't find any, find the stories that have the
potential to become 50-cent stories, and decide on what the writer could
have done to make the piece stronger.
- Are your lips
moving?
Recommended by: Laurie Hertzel, Minneapolis Star Tribune
Read your story out loud. You will hear awkward phrases and know if
a sentence is too long or difficult to read.
Assignment: Read a story out loud and see if, in doing so, you find
places where the flow doesn't work or where you'd make changes of any
sort based on what you hear.
- Search and destroy
Recommended by: Laurie Hertzel, Minneapolis Star Tribune
Search and destroy. That is, after your first draft do a computer search
on weak words (there, it, etc.) or weak verbs or (in my case) adverbs
(do a search on LY) or any other phrases or words you tend to use as
a crutch, and then change them to something stronger.
Assignment: Go through an article and highlight the weak words identified
above and decide whether a new word or no word works better.
- Making a positive
out of a negative
Recommended by: Laurie Hertzel, Minneapolis Star Tribune
Convert negatives to positives? Figure out a way to say what is, instead
of what isn't. Saying what is usually shorter, clearer and more direct.
(Obviously, there are times when for various writerly reasons you want
to break this rule.)
Look for "not" and "wasn't" (or "isn't")
or "no" and see if it makes sense to rewrite.
Examples:
"The movie wasn't engaging and most people didn't stay for the
end."
Change to: "The movie was dull and people left early."
or,
"The City Council vote was not unanimous."
change to: "The council's vote was divided."
Assignment: Go through an article and find "negatives," sentences
that talk about things that aren't. See if they can be reworded to be
positive statements.
- Toddler with
a butcher knife
Recommended by: Lex Alexander, assistant features editor/CAR team leader,
Greensboro News & Record
Trust yourself with adjectives the way you would trust a toddler with
a butcher knife. Adjectives often imply subjective value judgments that
your reporting might or might not support (and that readers will interpret
as bias in either case).
Example: Find objective terms for what you're trying to convey. Don't
call the city council member "ineffective." Say he has set
a record for missed meetings, was on the winning side of only two disputed
votes in the past year and hasn't gotten a single motion or resolution
enacted since taking office.
Don't say Reporter X is lazy. Say that Reporter X has failed to consult
the internal archives for his stories, resulting in the following published
errors of fact ....
You get the idea.
It's longer, but it's fairer and more accurate.
Assignment: Go through an article and highlight all the adjectives and
decide what purpose the adjectives serve. Are they implying something?
Are they necessary? Are they a substitute for details?
- Who's the story
about?
Recommended by: Carolyn Bower, Tampa Tribune
Never assume that the official view is the peg of the story. When I
teach about writing, one of the points I urge reporters to consider
is whose story is this.
One example: City commissioner John Higgins will apologize to the woman
he ejected from a public meeting to settle her long and costly lawsuit
against him, the city attorney's office said.
(This is a classic case of the reporter forgetting he/she gathers information
and then determines the direction of the story.)
Rewritten: After two years of fighting city hall, Rita Moore, 72, is
getting what she wanted: A formal apology from ex-Mayor John Higgins.
Not perfect, but much, much better.
Assignment: Go through an article written about some kind of government-related
event, and decide if the point of view of the article should be changed
(Is it written through the eyes of the public officials, when it could
be stronger through the eyes of the taxpayers, residents of the community,
etc.)
- Read!
Recommended by: Lynn Kalber, The Palm Beach Post
My best tip is: Read good writers. Actually, the basic is "Just
READ!" - it's surprising how many reporters don't.
Assignment: Go through your papers and find nuggets of great writing.
Share with your group what makes these nuggets great - strong detail,
great quote, clean writing, concise language, etc. Find one of your
favorite things.
- Tell that story
in one word
Recommended by: Michelle Hiskey, reporter, Atlanta Journal Constitution
Attach a ONE WORD theme to your story - i.e. greed, monopoly, trust,
hunger, etc. -- to keep you focused.
Assignment: Go through an article and see if you can apply one word
to it - a theme as identified above. Then look back over the article
and see if there are places in the story that deviate from this theme
and therefore don't belong. Does giving a theme or one word to the story
make you want to make changes or adjust the story in some way?
- Details, details
Recommended by: John Hatcher, Center for Community Journalism
Assignment: It's been said that great writing is rich with detail and
lean on fluff. Go through an article and find the details that show
a journalist was paying attention, not just to what people were saying,
but to where they were saying it, how they were saying it, and what
was going on around them as it was being said. If you can't find an
example of this, find an example of a story that would have been helped
with these same details.
- The great jargon
hunt
Recommended by: unknown
Assignment: Go through an article and highlight all jargon words. These
are the words used by public officials, police officers and sports writers
that may not make any sense to the average readers. Look at those words
and see if you can find a way to translate them for the reader.
- Steve's favorites
Recommended by: Steve Buttry, Writing Coach/National Correspondent,
Omaha World-Herald
Write as you report. Don't wait until you've gathered all your information
to start telling the story.
Don't insist on writing the lede first. Sometimes the process of writing
the story will bring out the best lede.
Write without notes. Notes can be a distraction. The story should be
in your head and your heart. Go back to the notes for fact-checking.
- Before you write
Recommended by: Nancy Weil, Assistant News Editor, IDG News Service
Organize notes and information, developing a system that works for you.
Different color inks, stars, whatever. Use story wheels or write down
key points of the story before you write so that you don't forget any
of the elements you want to include.
- Walk away
Recommended by: Nancy Weil, Assistant News Editor, IDG News Service
Provided you aren't on right-this-second deadline, leave the office
if you get stuck. Likewise, get up and move around when you're working
on long stories or stories with difficult topics (get away from the
murder and mayhem you are writing about). Take a walk outside. Go to
your favorite store and immerse yourself in the tactile pleasures of
shopping for 15 or 20 minutes, relax and let your mind go where it wants
with the story.
|